How to Pick the Right Shingles and Supplies for a Strong, Lasting Fix
Choosing materials for asphalt shingle repair starts with matching the new shingles to your current roof. The color, style, and shingle type should be as close as possible to what is already installed. You also need the right nails, sealant, and underlayment. When you pick materials that fit your climate and roof type, your repair will last longer and blend in better.
What You Need Before Starting
Before you begin asphalt shingle repair, take a close look at your roof. Bring a small sample of the damaged shingle to a local supplier if you can. This helps you match the color and texture.
Here is what you may need:
- Matching asphalt shingles
- Roofing nails with wide heads
- Roofing cement or sealant
- Underlayment if the layer below is damaged
- A flat pry bar and hammer
If your roof is older, the exact color may not be available. In that case, pick the closest shade. Over time, sun and weather will help the new shingles blend in.
Step-by-Step Overview of Material Selection
Use these simple steps to guide your choices:
- Identify your shingle type. Most homes use three-tab or architectural shingles.
- Check the weight and size. New shingles should line up with the old rows.
- Match the color as closely as possible.
- Pick nails that are long enough to go through the shingle and into the decking.
- Choose a roofing cement that works with asphalt products.
If the damage goes below the shingle, inspect the decking. Soft or rotted wood must be replaced before laying new shingles. Skipping this step can lead to leaks later.
Pros and Cons of Common Shingle Options
When choosing materials for asphalt shingle repair, you may see different options on the shelf. Each has benefits and drawbacks.
- Three-tab shingles: Lower cost and lighter weight. They are flat and simple but may not last as long in high winds.
- Architectural shingles: Thicker and layered. They handle wind better and often last longer, but they cost more.
- Impact-rated shingles: Built for hail areas. They are tougher but may not match older standard shingles exactly.
If your current roof uses architectural shingles, do not swap in three-tab shingles for a quick fix. The shape and height will not match, and the repair will stand out.
Mistakes People Make When Choosing Materials
One common mistake is picking shingles based on color alone. Size and style matter just as much. A slight size difference can cause gaps or uneven lines.
Another mistake is reusing old nails. Nails can rust or bend during removal. Fresh roofing nails hold better and reduce the risk of blow-offs.
Some homeowners also skip replacing damaged underlayment. If water has reached that layer, it must be fixed. A new shingle on top of wet felt will not solve the problem.
Best Fit by Situation
Your choice may depend on why you need asphalt shingle repair.
- Wind damage: Choose shingles with a higher wind rating and use proper nail placement.
- Hail damage: Consider impact-rated shingles if many areas are affected.
- Small isolated leak: Focus on a tight color and size match for a clean look.
- Older roof near end of life: A small repair may help short term, but a full is sometimes the smarter move.
If large sections are missing or curling, patchwork may not blend well. In that case, replacing a full slope may look better than several small repairs.
When to Call a Professional
Simple asphalt shingle repair can be a weekend project for some homeowners. But steep slopes, high roofs, or wide damage zones are different. Walking on a roof can be risky without proper safety gear.
If you see sagging decking, widespread granule loss, or repeated leaks in the same spot, it is smart to have a trained roofer inspect it. A professional can check ventilation, flashing, and other parts that affect how long your repair will last.
Get Help With the Right Materials and Repairs
If you need help with asphalt shingle repair in Los Lunas, NM, we are ready to guide you through the best material choices for your roof. At D&V Roofing LLC, we handle repairs of all sizes and make sure new shingles blend in well and hold up to the weather. Call us at (505) 535-3468 to schedule an inspection or talk through your options with our team.